Skip Navigation

News

Egypt approves commercialisation of first GM crop

Wagdy Sawahel

13 May 2008 | EN

maize_flickr_simplologist

Flickr/simpologist

[CAIRO] Egypt has approved the cultivation and commercialisation of a Bt maize variety, marking the first legal introduction of genetically modified (GM) crops into the country.

A report last month (16 April) from the US Department of Agriculture, noted that the Egyptian Ministry of Agriculture had "approved decisions made by the National Biosafety Committee and Seed Registration Committee to allow for commercialisation of a genetically modified Bt corn variety".

The endorsement was based on a series of field trials conducted between 2002 and 2007 for the variety MON 810, produced by biotechnology company Monsanto. Bt crops produce a toxin that guards against pests.

The variety to be distributed, Ajeeb-YG, is a cross between MON 810 and an Egyptian maize variety with resistance to three corn borer pests, developed by Monsanto scientists in South Africa — currently the only African country planting GM crops commercially.

Cairo-based company Fine Seeds International is partnering with Monsanto to distribute the variety in Egypt.

Ahmad Yaseen, an agricultural engineer at Fine Seeds, says the seeds will be available this month to farmers in ten Egyptian governorates.

Yaseen said the seeds will initially be imported from South Africa, but "starting from next year, Ajeeb-YG will be produced in Egypt".

Amr Farouk Abdelkhalik, an Egyptian biotechnologist and regional coordinator of the Agricultural Biotechnology Network in Africa, says the new variety "points to the potential agronomic and environmental benefits of Bt maize in Egyptian cropping systems and accordingly the reduction of the massive use of pesticides".

"We should develop our own GM plants using our genes and technology to protect small-scale farmers," he added.

Magdi Tawfik Abdelhamid, a plant biotechnologist at the National Research Centre in Cairo, expressed concerns about the long-term effects of the crop.

He says research on the issues surrounding GM crops "must be conducted in Egypt, and an in-depth assessment must be carried out to examine the impact of GM plants on small-scale farmers".

Egypt currently has no official biosafety legislation, though a regulatory framework exists. Hisham El-Shishtawy from the National Biosafety Committee secretariat told SciDev.Net that the existing framework follows the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety and encompasses ministerial decrees regulating the registration of GM seeds.

Comments

Ossama El-Tayeb ( Cairo University | Egypt )

22 May 2008

1. On 12 February the NBC approved import of 960 kg of the seeds for further trials with a condition that such trials will be contained and that a risk assessment in the recieving environment will be conducted. No mention was made of open environment planting, placing on the market or commercialization. 2. The Seed Registration Committee is not empowered to consider the release of GMOs into the environment. According to the CPB, which is the only legal instrument formally regulating LMOs in Egypt the Competent National Authority is the Nature Conservation Sector at the Ministry of State for the Environment, to which no application was made.

Nagib Nassar ( Brazil )

10 July 2008

In the end of the day , it is discovered that what was originally an egyptian variety ,is no more than the Bt corn Mon 810 y well known by being hated, forbidden and banned by majority of european nations and even all african countries, except... south Africa. Now it is registered in Egypt...with all seriuos bad consequences !!!!...As a Brazilian scientist having his deep roots in Egypt, feels his heart up with Egyptian poor farmers who will end up eating poisoned corn and suffer from this toxic transgenic crop. I wish to explain that egyptian small and poor farmers depend on rotation as a way of natural fertilization to their soil by nitrogen fixation. This will not be possible in future. simply because bt toxin produced by bt plant , mixed with calloids, will kill azotobacter totally. Unfortunately this aspect never been evaluated by authorities responsible to releasingg this variety in Egypt. (...continued) The same authorities did not consider at all how much be heavy the cost of such variety to small farmer , how much they will pay for 1 kg for this type of bt corn? Poor farmer is obligated to distroy any seed that may be used for future plantation. He must buy from the multinational new seed for his plantation. When farmer destroys seed, he destroys in the meantime genetic variability which may benefit in future plantation . He destroys his independence from multinationals, a principle for which his ancestors struggled through years and centuries. He will be be prisonned for the transgenic variety and for the multinationl. No any alternation but only buying it. Expensive, very little useful, and contaminating for the wild life and toxic even for himself. Is this compatible with food crisis in Egypt?

Add your comment

All comments are subject to approval and we reserve the right to edit comments containing inappropriate/unsuitable language. SciDev.Net holds copyright for all material posted on the website. Please see terms of use for further details.

You need to be signed in to post a comment or to email a consenting comment author. Please sign in or sign up.

Back to News
To the top