Biologist quits editorial board over cloning paper
Gearhart, a biologist at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, says that in agreeing to publish the work, the journal had failed to uphold scientific standards.
He argues that the research — conducted by the US company Advanced Cell Technology and published in the 26 November issue of the online journal e-biomed: The Journal of Regenerative Medicine — is lacking in several important respects.
Reference: Nature 414, 570 (2001)
Link to full text