Bringing science and development together through news and analysis

  • Scientists challenge deforestation study


Scientists have criticised a study published last year which suggested that earlier estimates of worldwide tropical deforestation and atmospheric carbon emissions were too high.

The original study by Frederic Achard and his colleagues — which was based on satellite imagery and published in Science last August — calculated that deforestation rates were 23 per cent lower than current UN Food and Agriculture Organisation estimates (see 'Global deforestation has been overestimated').

But in an article in this week's issue of Science, Philip M Fearnside of the Brazilian National Institute for Amazonian Research and William F Laurance of the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute in Panama claim that the study contains serious flaws.

For example, they say that estimates of forest biomass were far too low, that the researchers failed to include dead material in the study, and that incorrect assumptions were made about regeneration of forests on abandoned land.

"The cumulative effect of these omissions and other [assumptions] is a large underestimate of greenhouse gas emissions," say Fearnside and Laurance.

The authors of the original study reject this assertion, saying that they "find their comments less than convincing for the Brazilian Amazon,” and that their critics “produce no evidence at all contesting our global biomass estimates or global deforestation rates."

But they also acknowledge that lack of local data on forest biomass remains a major problem in making global estimates about deforestation.

© SciDev.Net 2003

Photo credit: FAO

We encourage you to republish this article online and in print, it’s free under our creative commons attribution license, but please follow some simple guidelines:
  1. You have to credit our authors.
  2. You have to credit SciDev.Net — where possible include our logo with a link back to the original article.
  3. You can simply run the first few lines of the article and then add: “Read the full article on SciDev.Net” containing a link back to the original article.
  4. If you want to also take images published in this story you will need to confirm with the original source if you're licensed to use them.
  5. The easiest way to get the article on your site is to embed the code below.
For more information view our media page and republishing guidelines.