[NAIROBI] East African environmental specialists have questioned new research that concludes that that climate change will bring increased drought, rather than more rain, to the region.
But the prediction contradicts the scenario of increased rainfall projected by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).
The researchers, from the University of California, Santa Barbara, studied temperature, wind speed and precipitation data over the last 20–30 years to determine what was driving climate variations in the tropical Indian and Pacific Ocean regions.
They found that the Indian Ocean has warmed particularly fast, increasing rainfall over the ocean and the westward movement of dry air over Eastern Africa — hence decreasing rainfall.
The severe food shortages experienced by millions of people in Ethiopia, Kenya and Somalia will be exacerbated by increased drought in the future, said the researchers.
Their work supports efforts by the US Geological Survey and the US Agency for International Development (USAID) to better target food aid by pinpointing areas of potential drought, and informing agricultural, environmental and water resources projects.
But the conclusions were dismissed by some East African climate researchers.
Richard Odingo of the University of Nairobi and former vice chair of the IPCC said the research was "half-baked" and served only US relief interests in the region.
He said it was erroneous to say the IPCC was wrong as the organisation used data going back 300 years from many different sources, as well as taking into account links between weather systems high in the Earth's atmosphere.
Benson Ochieng', an environment lawyer with the Institute for Law and Environmental Governance agreed. "The bottom-line in arriving at a conclusive result is to rely on many facets of the weather because climate is controlled by many atmospheric facets," he said.
But Park Williams, co-author of the paper and a postdoctoral fellow at the University of California, Santa Barbara, said global models [such as those produced by the IPCC] have a notoriously difficult time accurately simulating rainfall patterns over tropical land masses.
"Global models are tending to forecast a global trend toward a more El Niño-like climate which would, for example, generally mean more rainfall for Ethiopia and Kenya during the March to June period.
"It would be unwise just to look at the [rainfall] maps produced by the IPCC and take them at face value," he told SciDev.Net.
"We did not set out to debunk the IPCC report. Our role was to examine the data and the science behind it."
"People put a lot of confidence in the IPCC reports but there are a lot of caveats. There is still a lot of uncertainty in their models. We are quite comfortable using other models to come to other conclusions."
Climate Dynamics doi: 10.1007/s00382-010-0984-y (2011)