Skip Navigation

Opinions

  • Print
  • Comment
  • | Share

Indian science needs irreverence

Source: Science

3 May 2010 | EN

Indian girl and her mother look at a map

Flickr/DFID – UK Department for International Development

For India to successfully address local and global challenges and nurture future science leaders, Indian scientists must embrace a spirit of irreverence, says R. A. Mashelkar, president of the Global Research Alliance National Chemical Laboratory.

Indian culture, where "the words of the elders are the ultimate truth", condemns the irreverence inspired by the constant questioning that is essential in science, says Mashelkar. The country's education system, which is textbook-centred rather than student-centred, compounds this attitude, as does heavy bureaucracy, he adds.

The result is that, even if an institute wants to support 'audacious' ideas, finding fundable proposals is difficult, says Mashelkar.

But things are starting to change. India's higher education system is rapidly expanding, with thirty new universities and five Indian Institutes of Science Education and Research that will help to create a new culture of innovation through interactive learning methods and new evaluation systems.

Foreign companies are setting up research centres at a rapid pace, and filling them with many Indian returnees from abroad who bring innovation and new work perspectives to the table.

The recent launch of Tata Nano — the world's least expensive car — shows that a new spirit of adventurism is being embraced by some Indian companies.

"Hopefully, this spirit will rub off onto other enterprises and institutions," says Mashelkar.
 

Comments (2)

Dr.A.Jagadeesh ( Nayudamma Centre for Development Alternatives | India )

7 May 2010

I agree with you, Dr.Mashelkarji. There is vast talent in India. Unfortunately bureaucratic intervention in education and science is hindering the progress. Creativity, innovation and invention should be buzzwords. the Indian education system needs to be revamped to suit the needs of society. Mere bookish knowledge is not enough; it should be coupled with practical application. Dr.A.Jagadeesh Nellore(AP),India

rk sarkar ( India )

13 May 2010

Dr. Mashelkar's observation is correct and Indian scientist will do excellent work in future. But so many puzzled have to be solved. Presently Government policy is to destroy the old Institute. Gov. is very much reluctant to improve the status of the old Institute, so less staff and resources. It may happen to new Institute also. Our policy is VOTE oriented.
The funding agency and the people associated with them can get enlighten when something publish from outside the country. When they get knowledge it is already old and some short of breakthrough research is unimaginable to Indian Scientist. However, they are very efficient as a follower. Take any field: we become knowledgeable on the knowledge develop by others but we are very much backward to create new knowledge.
STILL I BELIEVE THE SITUATION WILL IMPROVE AND FOR THAT MATTER WE NEED MORE TRANSPERANCY IN PROJECT EVALUATION, FUNDING PATTERN AND ACCOUNTABILITY FROM SCIENTIST AND SCIENTIFIC ADMINISTRATOR (MORE CULPRIT).

Add your comment

This is your network: share your views on any of our articles by adding your comments.

You need to be signed in to post a comment or to email a consenting comment author. Please sign in or sign up.

All comments are subject to approval and we reserve the right to edit comments containing inappropriate/unsuitable language. SciDev.Net holds copyright for all material posted on the website. Please see terms of use for further details.

All SciDev.Net material is free to reproduce providing that the source and author are appropriately credited. For further details see Creative Commons.

Back to Opinions
To the top