Skip Navigation

Health: Brain drain

Opinions

  • Print
  • Comment
  • | Share

India's 'brain drain' tactics can work elsewhere

Source: Science

28 September 2010 | EN | 中文

India is community building in a bid to unite young scientists

Gopal Aggarwal

An Indian experiment to attract talented young science researchers back from abroad and foster a new scientific culture in the biological sciences is a model that could be used in other countries, argue Shubha Tole and Ronald D. Vale in Science.

Instead of offering lavish resources to established US or European scientists, as in China or Singapore, say the authors, it is coaxing young foreign-trained Indian scientists to return by establishing grant programmes to support post-doctoral work and new independent laboratories.

In the last two years, an annual Young Investigator Meeting has brought together some 40 postdoctoral fellows considering careers in India with successful local counterparts engaged in research programmes in the country. Senior foreign and Indian scientists and policymakers also attend.

Social networking is strongly encouraged by the programme as a way of forming research collaborations, and a website has been set up to provide information on grants, jobs and issues such as combining teaching with research.

The major challenge, argue the authors, is changing the mindset of expatriate scientists who remember poor laboratory facilities from their undergraduate days. Yet new buildings and equipment cannot themselves create success, they say: "The best guarantee for future success is to imbue young scientists with a sense of a mission, to nurture not just the science but a culture that fuels the will to succeed in countries long thought of as second-choice options for research careers."

Link to full article in Science

Comments (1)

Dr.A.Jagadeesh ( Nayudamma Centre for Development Alternatives | India )

26 April 2011

Brain-drain has been a matter of much concern to the developing countries. People trained at high cost in developing countries are drained away by advanced countries where they contribute to their growth at a time when they are desperately needed for the same purpose at home. To a developing country, it is not only a severe strain on the financial resources but also a serious threat to successful development efforts and execution of economic, industrial and social changes that are so badly needed in developing countries.

The problem of brain-drain can be tackled in three different ways:
1. Reversing the brain-drain
2. Making use of the scientists and technologists while they are abroad
3. By controlling and regulating the migration of the scientists going abroad.

In countries like the USA, the position is becoming increasingly difficult for Indians to get employment or retain the existing positions. The time is therefore opportune for bringing back the Indian Scientists. It is not as though India could not afford to bring back every Indian but at least where there are well defined and relevant national tasks, we should attempt to bring the scientists where their talents and training could be matched with the tasks.

But before we do that, it is good to understand the psychology of our scientists abroad. It is not that the Indians abroad do not want to come back to our country; in fact quite a few with brilliant record have returned with special skills and experience which have been put to good use, But some come back and also left disillusioned. Why is this? They say it is not the lack of comfort or salaries that drive them away; but it is the environment lacking in challenging opportunities, lacking in the required degree of flexibility, freedom, flow of thought that suffocates them. There is also lack of proper system for ready recognition and rewarding of merit. What is called for then is a change in our approach; a change in our vertical, hierarchial sys

Add your comment

This is your network: share your views on any of our articles by adding your comments.

You need to be signed in to post a comment or to email a consenting comment author. Please sign in or sign up.

All comments are subject to approval and we reserve the right to edit comments containing inappropriate/unsuitable language. SciDev.Net holds copyright for all material posted on the website. Please see terms of use for further details.

All SciDev.Net material is free to reproduce providing that the source and author are appropriately credited. For further details see Creative Commons.

Back to Opinions
To the top