Skip Navigation

Letters to the Editor

  • Print
  • Comment
  • | Share

Biofuels and carbon capture a 'catastrophe' for mankind

Dr David Hill

Chief Executive
World Innovation Foundation
Bern, Switzerland

3 January 2008 | EN

The decisions being taken by governments around the world in the quest for sustainability are a catastrophe for humankind in the long-term. Two of these decisions currently at the forefront of news are biofuels, and carbon capture and storage (see Biofuel revolution threatens food security for the poor).

Biofuels — the fuel revolution that will supposedly help us:

(1) Growing crops in the United States for biofuels requires around the same energy input for fertilisers and processing the crops as that saved by replacing petrol on the forecourt (Biofuels - A solution worse than the problem, Daily Telegraph).

(2) By harvesting the peat bogs for biofuels, we release 30 times more carbon dioxide than will be recouped by burning the biofuel produced (Prof. Jack Riley, University of Nottingham).

(3) Growing biofuels takes a lot of land and huge amounts of water — neither of which the world has to spare.

(4) China and India risk famine if they proceed with their biofuels plans, because they don't have enough water to grow both fuel and food (International Water Management Institute).

(5) Biofuels are killing forests and leading to more global warming, besides taking land away from food crops (Global Forest Coalition).

(6) The diversion of land meant for food crops to agrofuel production is a "crime against humanity" (Jean Ziegler, UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food).

Carbon Capture — putting off today what others will have to solve tomorrow:

(1) Carbon sequestration and storage (under our oceans and land) is an untried method of locking up carbon dioxide forever, but there is not a 100 per cent assurance that it will not escape. Possible escape routes include earthquakes, land shifts, terrorism (holding the world to ransom) or human disasters/accidents.

(2) Sequestration and storage of carbon dioxide is not a solution, but a problem that humankind will have to face in the future — one that might eventually threaten the existence of human life itself on Earth, for nothing ever designed has lasted forever.

(3) Governments, as usual, are only looking at solving problems today without any understanding of what this will bring in the future. They are attempting to lock up gases that are toxic to humans — leaving any problems for future generations to solve.

(4) If there was a rupture in the storage vessel, the ramifications for the world would be immense, to say the very least. Therefore, carbon capture is a method of putting off  today what others will have to fix tomorrow (if they can).

Comments (1)

Dr David Hill ( THE WIFC | Switzerland )

19 March 2011

The realisation that carbon capture is more of a threat to future humankind than a blessing can vividly be displayed by the recent catastrophic Japanese earthquake and tsunami. In this respect one has only to imagine what the rupture of a vast undersea chamber, storing billions upon billions of cubic metres of carbon dioxide gas would do to humanity. The flooding into the earth's lower atmosphere would be utterly devastating and kill millions if not billions of people in the process. The killing fields of Cambodia would melt into insignificance on this grand scale of human death. Indeed, what would be the greatest human disaster of all time and could very well lead to the total decimation of the human experience itself. Do we really want to take this risk, for it is not an unnatural event that could not happen. Reality has therefore to step in to save such a possible future catastrophe happening and where common-sense has to be paramount here. Financial gain is fine, but not when the death of humanity could be very well be the eventual price that we all pay. We have therefore to think of our children and their children and then we may allow common sense to prevail. I hope with all my heart and mind that it does.

Dr David Hill
Executive Director
World Innovation Foundation Charity
Bern, Switzerland

Add your comment

This is your network: share your views on any of our articles by adding your comments.

You need to be signed in to post a comment or to email a consenting comment author. Please sign in or sign up.

All comments are subject to approval and we reserve the right to edit comments containing inappropriate/unsuitable language. SciDev.Net holds copyright for all material posted on the website. Please see terms of use for further details.

All SciDev.Net material is free to reproduce providing that the source and author are appropriately credited. For further details see Creative Commons.

Back to Letters to the Editor
To the top

Information Services

Want to reach out?

Advertise events, jobs, grants and announcements to a global audience