
Science and Development Network
News, views and information about science, technology and the developing world
The majority of smallholders in East Africa lack access to the best quality breeds
Flickr/angela7dreams
[NAIROBI] Dairy farmers in East Africa could soon benefit from superior, affordable cattle breeds through a US$1 million research project.
The Dairy Genetics East Africa (DGEA) initiative aims to help smallholders take full advantage of the region's booming dairy sector and improve their incomes by giving them access to top quality breeds better suited to their local environments.
The International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI) will collaborate with the University of New England, Australia, and non-profit consulting firm PICO Eastern Africa (PICOTEAM), to collect information from Kenyan and Ugandan farmers about which breeds they prefer and why, and collect genetic samples from the animals those farmers currently own.
DGEA will also examine environmental factors such as rainfall and water availability, temperature and available feed resources, to match breeds to local ecological zones.
At the end of the three-year project partners hope to develop a business plan in collaboration with the private sector, through which better quality animals will be bred and sold to smallholders at affordable prices.
"This innovative idea seeks to address historical constraints to dairy development in East Africa more broadly," said Ed Rege, a project leader at PICOTEAM.
The majority of smallholders starting dairy farming or wishing to breed or replace their cows do not have access to breeds that best match their production environments, said Okeyo Mwai, the project's coordinator at ILRI.
Many farmers also lack evidence-based knowledge about which breeds are most appropriate for their production systems or where to obtain them, he said. They usually buy new cattle from their neighbours or large commercial farms — but these are often ill-suited to their local conditions, he added.
"This project aims to use on-farm data to assess the performance of the various dairy cattle genotypes, in order to determine how they perform under a range of farm conditions," said Mwai.
Mathew Kibaara, a private veterinary practitioner and Kenya's former deputy director of veterinary services, welcomed the initiative but warned it would take more than the planned three years to produce results.
"Three years is not adequate to carry out a field study on the cows kept and reasons for preferences, conduct genotyping to come up with improved breeds and have them ready for sale," he told SciDev.Net.
Wanyama ( Kenya )
28 March 2011
Dear Editor, SciDev.Net
I would like to say this a very interesting and innovative project. I would like to applaud the team that has come-up with this. But my biggest worry is: What happens to the livestock keepers’ rights to recognition of their role in producing and conserving these diverse animal genetic resources that will form the basis (seed stock) for the development of the "supper breed"? What parallel can one make here with such cases as the one of a heat resistant organism that was found somewhere in one of the hot springs of the Rift Valley which ended up being commercialized without regard of the source? I suggest that this project works very closely with the indigenous livestock keepers, not just as givers of information and genetic materials, but also as decision makers of what happens to this information and materials. The project should also link-up with organizations that are more versed with issues relating to Access and Benefit Sharing and community participation. One component this project must have is the development of Bio-cultural Protocols with each of the communities from which the genetic materials will be sampled and researched on. I also just wonder whether due consideration has been made of how the past success of the Diary Industry had devastating effect on the animal genetic diversity in the so called high potential areas.
Jacob Wanyama
LIFE Network Africa
E-mail: jacob_wanyama@yahoo.com
Ilse Köhler-Rollefson ( India )
28 March 2011
I find this approach a bit worrying. Once again, livestock keepers are cast as people who dont know what they are doing and that require support by scientsits and the private sector to breed - when they are actually the ones with the record of developing a large number of optimally adapted livestock breeds. It is extremely important that livestock keepers themselves remain active breeders rather than just purchasing animals from a company.
And, by the way, having high milk yielding cows does not necessarily translate into higher profits for the producers. It will only mean that milk will become cheaper and the main beneficiaries will be consumers, but not the dairy producers. This is evident from the situation of dairy farmers in Europe. So, I am sorry, despite all the good intentions, it seems to me that this project will benefit scientists and the private sector, but not the dairy farmers!
All comments are subject to approval and we reserve the right to edit comments containing inappropriate/unsuitable language. SciDev.Net holds copyright for all material posted on the website. Please see terms of use for further details.
All SciDev.Net material is free to reproduce providing that the source and author are appropriately credited. For further details see Creative Commons.
27 May 2012